
Part 1: The Six-Figure Penalty That Survives Your Corporation
Limited liability does not protect you from payroll and sales tax failures. Not in the US. Not in Canada. This is the risk most owners genuinely don't know about, and it's the most serious one in this series.
Income tax, Social Security, and Medicare withheld from employee paycheques never legally belong to your business. You hold that money in trust for the Treasury. If a “responsible person” “wilfully” fails to remit it, the IRS can assess a penalty equal to 100% of the unpaid trust fund taxes against that person individually - owners, officers, partners, bookkeepers, anyone with authority over the funds.
“Wilful” is a lower bar than it sounds: per IRS guidance, you're acting wilfully if you pay other business expenses instead of the withholding taxes. And multiple people can be assessed jointly and severally for the same liability.
For a business running roughly $100,000 USD in quarterly payroll, $20,000–$30,000 USD of each quarter's Form 941 liability is trust fund money. Three missed quarters produces six-figure personal exposure and that exposure survives the business closing.
In Canada, GST/HST collected from customers is treated the same way: as trust funds held for the government. Directors of a corporation can be held personally liable for unremitted HST and payroll source deductions (CAD). The corporate veil doesn't cover it. US sales tax works identically - it's a trustee tax, and states can pursue owners and officers directly if a business fails to pay an assessment.
The pattern across all three: money you collect or withhold on a government's behalf is never really yours and incorporating doesn't change that.
Part 1 of The Real Cost of Compliance Mistakes, a 16-part series on what accounting compliance failures actually cost US and Canadian businesses.
Not sure if your payroll deposits are current? A quick review can confirm it.
This post is general information, not tax, legal, or accounting advice for your specific situation. Confirm your obligations with a qualified professional before acting.